The other day, I was listening to the american-idiot album by Green Day and felt myself feeling the exact same way I invariably do when I hear this band. I like Green Day and, although I didn't know about with them when they were an underground punk sensation, I purchased Dookie when it came out. This was the first album the group put out for a mainstream audience, and me liked it. I've always felt that they were not incredibly punk rock. I'll admit, I do not know how Green Day orginally sounded since I haven't heard their work from before Dookie. Still, I have heard many of their songs and I don't feel it's really punk music. Yep, it is angst ridden, the instrumentation is straightforward, and the singing is nasally. All of these aspects go into good Punk Music. Yet, if this is all there's to punk, next Slim Shady should be though of as a punk rocker.
Green Day does not make Punk Music from the way I see it. This is distinctly true of their 'american idiot' CD. This CD is in my album collection and I do like listening to it occasionally.
Commercial radio and punk don't mix!
However, when I do, it isn't since I would like to listen to Punk Music. If I am in the mood for punk rock, I pull out one of my XS-Energy, Stage B, Tax Exiles, or Johnny Moped CDs. With these Punk bands, I get the anger and the mad fast beats punk-music is meant to have. I mean, come on, if it is appropriate for the radio it can't incredibly be punk! Green Day makes damm good music, however they are not a punk band.